Press
Return to INSURGENTTHEATRE.ORG
Press:

Previews:
Riverwest Currents published this preview
Shepherd Express published this preview

Reviews:
Vital Source Online published this review
Warning, this review spoils some of your surprises.
The Shepherd Express published this review
Warning, this review spoils all of your surprises
This is our response, not to the review, but to some of the issues the reviewer raises. We are willing to be misinterpreted by the audience, but when it comes to the press, we'd like to be able to put out our side of things.



Merry Marxmas: The Plight of the Ruling Class

by Jason Hart photo by Laura Gorzek

Theater

May 5 is Karl Marx’s birthday, but in the world of Entrepreneurial Communism, it’s also Marxmas. On Marxmas, Ben Turk has been known to dress as the author of The Communist Manifesto and take to the streets – to sell Marx-themed merchandise. You aren’t likely to see Turk this Marxmas, because he’ll be busy with The Plight of the Ruling Class, a new collection of one-act plays being produced by Insurgent Theatre, the company he co-founded and runs with Tracy Doyle.

Insurgent Theatre launched under the name S-MartKino in 2003. Director and actor Doyle teamed up with Turk, who writes. Their vision was to bring high quality, locally produced political theatre to the masses, and to change America’s current political system while doing so.

Entrepreneurial Communism guides the practice of Insurgent Theatre. This theory, at first glance an inherent contradiction, was formed by Turk while he was a Political Science student at UWM. Turk explains it this way: “It’s communist because it believes in an overhaul of our economic system, where the worker receives the full product of their labor. It’s entrepreneurial because it aims to achieve that by going into business instead of politics.”

Entrepreneurial communism works like this: the revenues from each show are split 50/50, with half divided evenly amongst all of the cast and crew, and with the other half being used as seed money for the next show. Insurgent is also careful about where and how they spend their money: “We won’t sell ads in the program to someone who isn’t a small, local business. We won’t buy shit at Wal-mart. We try to keep it as small and local as possible.”

The Plight of the Ruling Class is a set of three one-acts that focuses on incendiary issues: racism, Muslim rights, rape. The plays are written by Turk and Milwaukee playwright John Manno. Doyle is directing two of the pieces, and Alamo Basement’s Mike Q. Hanlon is directing the third. I watched an early run-through of the plays, and I was blown away by the quality of the acting and writing, and also by the courage demonstrated by their choice of topics.

Cured, the play written by Manno, is especially interesting. Set in an alternate version of reality, Cured makes a statement about our blind acceptance of cultural norms and practices. I’ve been asked not to reveal the most shocking parts of Cured, and I won’t. I don’t enjoy learning crucial information about pieces before I see them. I’ll only say that you should make every attempt to see this play, or have someone who does tell you what it’s about.

Insurgent’s most memorable project was the original full-length one act Bring the War Home, about 1960s radical group The Weather Underground. Bring the War Home was written by Turk, and directed by Doyle. It was the first play produced in Insurgent’s current home, the Astor Theatre, and sold out every performance except for one during a massive blizzard.

Insurgent loves nothing so much as conflict. It’s disappointing to them, then, that self-selecting audiences at previous shows have led to unitary interpretations of their work. “No one disagreed with us. We were hoping we could create a discussion. It was more people who agreed with each other talking amongst themselves,” Turk said of the talkback afterwards.

“That’s something we’re addressing in the rewrite,” said Doyle. “We are addressing the concern that most left-wingers saw it as a push towards doing the things the Weather Underground were doing. It wasn’t supposed to be pro-violence or pro-pacifism.”

“Ultimately, it’s a criticism of political action – that going and fighting the state is the way to change society,” said Turk. Insurgent prefers to work from within, believing that change is ultimately rooted in the economy. Their theory is that the first step is to develop new economic patterns and systems, and then the politics and society will fall into place.

They aim to transform the theatre scene too, bringing in people without experience. “There are a lot of people who have never done theatre before, and thought maybe that’s something I can do…” said Doyle. “But then they’re intimidated by the theatre scene,” continued Turk. Turk and Doyle do not come from theatre backgrounds – Doyle was a microbiology student and works in a lab, Turk has a degree in political science from UWM.

Insurgent has recently entered into collaboration with Milwaukee theatre groups Alamo Basement, The Paris Business Review, and Pink Banana. The four groups have formed a DIY collective to assist each other and to bring entertaining theatre to the Milwaukee community. Plight is the first show produced by this as-yet unnamed collective, using the talents of members of all four groups. Perhaps Milwaukee will be the home base of an entrepreneurial communist DIY theatre movement.

Insurgent Theatre’s Plight of the Ruling Class runs 8 PM May 3-6, 10-13 at the Astor Theatre (Inside of the Brady Street Pharmacy).
For more information visit www.insurgenttheatre.org

Riverwest Currents online edition - May, 2006

top



Wed. May 3
Plight of the Ruling Class @ Astor Theatre, 8 p.m.
Milwaukee’s Insurgent Theatre (formerly known as S-martkino) has been producing strong, political plays for a few years now, but this time they’ve outdone themselves. “Plight of the Ruling Class” is composed of three one-act plays, each centered on a touchy political issue (specifically: racism, terrorism and rape), each written by a Milwaukee playwright (John Manno, Ben Turk), and each sure to ignite controversy in the audience. If you like to be challenged, Insurgent is the theater company for you. The theater has limited capacity (43 seats), and Insurgent shows always sell out, so purchasing tickets in advance would be a good idea. The Astor Theatre is located in the Brady Street Pharmacy. Runs May 3-6 and 10-13. (Jason Hart)

top


WEB EXCLUSIVE!
Insurgent Theatre

by Russ Bickerstaff

Originally published 05/01/06 in Vital Source.

Still in its infancy, S-Martkino’s Insurgent Theatre remains deliciously unknown to the larger masses of Milwaukee Theatre goers. Resonating out of the Astor Theatre, its fourth show, “The Plight of The Ruling Class,” is a two-hour presentation of three fresh, compelling shorts written by local playwrights John Manno and Ben Turk. Each of the three stories carves-out a different path in the exploration of the dynamic between control and submission. As a whole, the show is captivatingly rough around the edges, sculpting an evening of drama that is at least as compelling as something you’d pay quite a bit more to see in another part of town.

The show opens with Manno’s chillingly dark comedy “Cured.” It follows the psychological journey of one Sarah Smith. Like any young idealist, she hates her family’s complicity with the way things are. All too aware and too disgusted by her society’s immorality, Sarah must decide whether or not she’s willing to assimilate into its corruption. Mary Diaz proves to be an impressive talent in the role of Sarah. She fills the central role with heart and compassion throughout the character’s progression. Alice Wilson fills the submissive June Cleaver-esque mother role with creepy effectiveness in a story like this. Shawn Smith is suitably authoritative in the role of her father John who runs the family business. As a playwright, Manno has real talent. As a play, “Cured” runs many thematic and stylistic parallels with British playwright Caryl Curchill’s much more accomplished “Far Away” (which was staged last season by Bialystock and Bloom). While “Cured” contains much more humor than Churchill’s play, it is also considerably darker, being much more firmly rooted in reality. The staging is a bit chilling. As seen numerous times over the course of the season, we once again see actors actually eating onstage in character. This time the eating itself plays a very stylishly visceral addition to a very fundamental aspect of the plot.

Following “Cured” and intermission, the production shifts gears for a pair of complimentary plays written by Insurgent Theatre co-founder Ben Turk. “Claire and George” stars Jason Hames as a government official who is forced to interrogate a friend and US immigrant who has made a bomb threat. Here Olivia Lopez plays Claire, a woman willing to do anything to see her husband who is being detained under the oppressive power of the USA Patriot Act. It’s a touching story that shows some of the tragedy and complexity of US-Middle-Eastern relations, but it feels a bit forced. Much of the dialogue sounds stilted and expository. There’s very little here for anyone who’s already familiar with US foreign policy. It’s a bit frustrating to watch, which would be fine if it were more engagingly frustrating.

The production closes with “George and Claire,” which begins in suspense and ends in tragedy through some rather strange comedy. In this instance, David Bohn plays George, a nice guy who loves his girlfriend Claire (daringly played here by Jody Tempas). Claire has a submissive, sado-masochistic fetish and desperately wants him to rape her. Being the nice guy he is, George can’t seem to bring himself to rape his girlfriend, which makes her feel bad. It seems to me that I’ve seen this type of story played out before, but I can’t imagine where. The ironic comedy here is priceless. Claire says, “Can’t you see you’re hurting me?” and she means that emotionally because he’s unwilling to hurt her physically. It’s this strange awkwardness of sexual communication that drives the entire play and more than makes-up for a rather weak, if thoroughly provocative, dramatic ending to an excellent evening’s theatre.

Insurgent Theatre’s “The Plight of the Ruling Class” runs now through May 13 at the Astor Theatre. Tickets are $15 in advance or $8 at the door. Visit Insurgent Theatre online at: http://insurgenttheatre.org for more information.  VS

Russ Bickerstaff - Russ Bickerstaff is a local poet and writer. His poems can be heard regularly at Linneman's Monday Poetry Night.

top



Provocative and Risky
Plight Succeeds In Spite of Stumbles
By Jason Hart

Cannibalism. Terrorism. Rape. Such are the subjects of Insurgent Theatre’s latest production, The Plight of the Ruling Class, a collection of three one-acts by Milwaukee playwrights. At the Astor Theatre through May 13, it’s a boxing match for your brain, and a guided tour of hell for your emotions.

Cured, written by John Manno, is the first and best play of the set. The home of John and Jane Smith is the same as many upper-class households. John runs the meat-processing company passed down to him by his father. Jane is a housewife who works with her church and charities to make the world a little better. Sarah, their only child, is a vegetarian, and rebels against the family business she is meant to one day run. But this world holds a horrible secret, one that we don’t discover until we are so deep inside of it that we have begun to mistake it for our own.

From the beginning of Cured, the dialogue captivates and the performances mesmerize. Manno withholds the choicest morsels of information from the audience, doling them out like bits of steak to eager dogs. We get hints throughout, but it isn’t until more than halfway through that we learn the whole truth: all of the characters, except Sarah, are cannibals. They don’t eat each other. They eat Africans. John Smith’s company breeds, slaughters and sells African people to American people.

Cured makes us wonder what atrocities we are complicit in. Just as the characters in the play are inherently responsible for their participation in the slaughter and devouring of other human beings, we are responsible for the sweatshops, slave labor and oppression that make our middle-class lives possible.

Cured’s major failing is its narrow focus. We only see this world through the eyes of Americans—there are no Africans on stage at any point. A diversity of viewpoints would have been welcome. I can’t help but shake the feeling that for all of its sensitivity to issues of race, this is still a play for white people, about white people.

Cured is directed by Mike Q. Hanlon, better known for his direction of comedy for Alamo Basement. Hanlon does an excellent job, especially with conversation: The silences in this play say as much as the words around them. The acting in Cured is also generally impressive. Mary Diaz, playing Sarah Smith, gives a nuanced and captivating performance. Cesar Gamino, as her nurse Jim, invests his character with gentle soul and delicate realism. Alice Wilson and Shawn Smith ring true as Jane’s parents, wrapped up in the banal evils of their world. Dan Ritter holds his own as David Getz, Sarah’s boyfriend.

Claire and George is the middle play, and the weakest of the three. The lights go up on a woman, wearing an Islamic head scarf, chained to a table. A DHS agent dressed in a crisp suit enters, and demands, “Where is it?” The “it” is a bomb that may or may not exist. Claire (changed from the Lebanese name Clarisa), her husband indefinitely held at Guantanamo Bay, has issued a bomb threat in a futile attempt to free him. The situation is interesting, but the characters quickly devolve into mouthpieces for political ideology, and the acting is generally one-dimensional.

The final play, George and Claire, is a better play than Claire and George, and is probably playwright Ben Turk’s best piece to date, but its messages are deeply problematic. In this play, Claire is a rich suburban girl who goads her boyfriend over and over again to fulfill her fantasy of being violently raped, until he finally gives in and rapes her, for real, while she begs him to stop. The rape takes place entirely in the dark, but it is still very, very disturbing to watch. The last line of the play belongs to George, who mutters, as he slinks from the room, “How could you do this to me?”

According to Turk’s comments during a talk-back session after opening night, this act is symbolic of the ruling class’ ability to always get what they want, even when what they want is to be brutalized. This explanation should not be accepted without question. The play is essentially a story about a woman being punished for seeking sexual fulfillment. Whatever meaning or symbolism one attempts to wrap around that is irrelevant to the fact that a woman is raped, and a man ends up the victim. Is it really fair to make women, 25% of whom are sexual abuse survivors, bear the emotional pain of this heavy-handed metaphor?

Their weaknesses notwithstanding, you should see these plays. This is some of the best theater being produced in Milwaukee, and certainly the best being written here. Cured in particular sparkles throughout with quality, and heralds Manno’s potential as a playwright of note. The others, despite their flaws, are still well worth your time.

top